Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945

Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945

Catherine Merridale / May 29, 2020

Ivan s War Life and Death in the Red Army A powerful groundbreaking narrative of the ordinary Russian soldier s experience of the worst war in history based on newly revealed sourcesOf the thirty million who fought in the eastern front of W

  • Title: Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945
  • Author: Catherine Merridale
  • ISBN: 9781429900706
  • Page: 473
  • Format: ebook
  • A powerful, groundbreaking narrative of the ordinary Russian soldier s experience of the worst war in history, based on newly revealed sourcesOf the thirty million who fought in the eastern front of World War II, eight million died, driven forward in suicidal charges, shattered by German shells and tanks They were the men and women of the Red Army, a ragtag mass of soldieA powerful, groundbreaking narrative of the ordinary Russian soldier s experience of the worst war in history, based on newly revealed sourcesOf the thirty million who fought in the eastern front of World War II, eight million died, driven forward in suicidal charges, shattered by German shells and tanks They were the men and women of the Red Army, a ragtag mass of soldiers who confronted Europe s most lethal fighting force and by 1945 had defeated it Sixty years have passed since their epic triumph, but the heart and mind of Ivan as the ordinary Russian soldier was called remain a mystery We know something about hoe the soldiers died, but nearly nothing about how they lived, how they saw the world, or why they fought.Drawing on previously closed military and secret police archives, interviews with veterans, and private letters and diaries, Catherine Merridale presents the first comprehensive history of the Soviet Union Army rank and file She follows the soldiers from the shock of the German invasion to their costly triumph in Stalingrad, where life expectancy was often a mere twenty four hours Through the soldiers eyes, we witness their victorious arrival in Berlin, where their rage and suffering exact an awful toll, and accompany them as they return home full of hope, only to be denied the new life they had been fighting to secure.A tour de force of original research and a gripping history, Ivan s War reveals the singular mixture of courage, patriotism, anger, and fear that made it possible for these underfed, badly led troops to defeat the Nazi army In the process Merridale restores to history the invisible millions who sacrificed the most to win the war.

    • [PDF] Download ✓ Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945 | by ✓ Catherine Merridale
      473 Catherine Merridale
    • thumbnail Title: [PDF] Download ✓ Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945 | by ✓ Catherine Merridale
      Posted by:Catherine Merridale
      Published :2020-02-08T22:10:49+00:00

    About "Catherine Merridale"

      • Catherine Merridale

        Catherine Merridale Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Ivan's War: Life and Death in the Red Army, 1939-1945 book, this is one of the most wanted Catherine Merridale author readers around the world.


    744 Comments

    1. The story of the Soviet war experience from the ground up as recorded through dozens of interviews with octogenarian veterans has a distinctly polycephalic feel to it. The passage of time has left Catherine Merridale with a drop out of an ocean’s worth of stories, but by the time you turn the last page it will become clear why this is for the best. It was not only dangerous to testify against the authorized tale of the war, it often became simply inconceivable for the survivors to recount thos [...]


    2. Before reading Ivan’s War I thought I knew a bit about how tough life in the Red Army could be. I’ve read Antony Beevor’s Stalingrad, and watched Jude Law run into the same city on screen, armed only with a handful of bullets and his steely desire to become an A-list action hero. As I knew it, Russian soldiers fought hard, died in droves and existed as cogs in a callous engine of destruction that chewed them up for fuel. This was all true, but by the time I had finished this book I realise [...]


    3. Red army, white death. I want a daughter with lips as red as blood. I want a son with translucent skin view-finding the reals of my backyard. The frozen over graveyard. Mother Russia ran into a door knob when the Fatherland had too much to drink and said let's conquer our neighbors today, tomorrow the world. The deserters walked off with the door. The only knobs with issued guns shot the deserters. There was a fairytale about Ivan, the Russian soldier with a stout heart. War as anatomically corr [...]


    4. This book is an astounding examination of the Red Army during World War II. Ms. Merridale examines the prelude: the purges of the officer corps in the late 1930’s, the invasion of Poland and the attack on Finland. She examines in detail the disastrous first years of the Nazi attack on the Soviet Union. She bases many of her findings on the now newly opened archives and interviews with surviving veterans. But she does not stop there, and realizes the limitations of these; veterans and letters h [...]


    5. Most books about WW2 at some point include a description of the Red Army as it sweeps westward across Europe. These tend towards the exotic - much mention of cossacks with whips, shaggy ponies pulling sleds side by side with tanks, etc. This one is almost totally - and refreshingly - devoid of that kind of thing. Which isn't to say the Red Army wasn't brutal and weird, but Merridale focuses on experiences that seem to have been the norm, in as much as there was any. There's a broad social contex [...]


    6. In this book the author attempts to look at the life of the Russian soldier of WW2 fame – ‘Ivan’. We get to see the Russian soldier fighting his way from the terrible early days of 1941 to the end of the war, not a pretty sight! The author uses numerous first-hand accounts to tell her story, overall not a bad book if you’re interested in the subject.


    7. Interesting and at the same time terrifying work. Absolutely breaks the heart to read about all those lives that were so easily expanded. This is due to the fact that at the beginning of the war it was a broken and an unprofessional army. More then that, even later on the soviet leadership thought of them merely as pawns and never as real people. Merridale did a great job in combining both personal experiences and actual history. A great plus is that although she does sees and is able to convinc [...]


    8. This is (yet another) of those "it might not be for everybody" books. In fact, I imagine those who don't care for history might find it "dull". Personally, I found it fascinating. An essential addition to any WWII buff's reading-list. If you know anything about WWII & the USSR it is usually thru sterilized US-based history (which often over-glorifies D-Day and minimalizes the USSR role) or it is thru the "traditional" USSR lens of the Patriotic War filled w/ heroic, selfless sacrifice for th [...]


    9. The mind reels at the fathomless suffering of the foot soldier in the Soviet army during WWII as well as their capacity to survive any hardship - short of murder - and privation - short of death by starvation - that man can devise. It added immensely to the understanding that I am developing of the nearly boundless suffering that the Soviet people endured from the Bolshevik Rev through the death of Stalin. Unimaginable.


    10. Great social history of the Red Army: This is a very well-written book about the people who fought in the Red Army and not a military history of that Army and its campaigns. As anyone who has ever spoken to fathers and uncles about WW2 knows, it is very difficult to get these men to open up. The author makes clear that the problem is even greater for members of the Red Army. Nevertheless, she did get real stories from the frontoviki and she weaves their stories beautifully into this terrific his [...]



    11. This is a book that demonstrates that good scholarship and accessible writing and human interest are in no way mutually exclusive. Merridale has thoroughly researched and documented her subject, yet has also been able to write a compelling book that should appeal to and inform the average reader. It is directly comparable to the work of Cornelius Ryan in “The Longest Day,” only better, because it is better researched and addresses a topic most English-speaking readers are unfamiliar with: th [...]


    12. Based on the author's interviews with actual participants of the Great Partiotic War.I'm glad I read Ivan's War, it provides some insight into life on the Eastern Front during the Second World War. But only a very shallow insight. It becomes very apparent that the author might not have an historical background, she also seems to have very little understanding of (or interest in) the war or military history. If Merridale were more knowledgable she might have produced an product similar to Stephen [...]


    13. Aunque mucho se ha escrito sobre la IIGM y sobre todos sus aspectos y contendientes, siempre hay algo nuevo que descubrir en relación con ese terrible acontecimiento. En este caso se trata de las peculiaridades del Ejército Rojo, cuyas batallas se contaban como carnicerías por la cantidad de bajas que recibía, pero que, sin embargo, supo mejorar y reorganizarse durante la contienda, acabando por dar un giro radical a la guerra.El libro está muy documentado y de él se puede obtener toda una [...]


    14. Not a well written piece. Forced myself to 50% on a Kindle version and then skipped to the last chapter. While the author did a great amount of research in archives and conducted many oral interviews with veterans, she ultimately failed to create an enjoyable and interesting writing from these sources. I feel like she tried to grasp too many things at once, not going into details where she should have and basically repeating herself where she shouldn't have. She used many excerpts from letters b [...]


    15. -Muy interesante aunque hay peros.-Género. Historia.Lo que nos cuenta. Acercamiento al soldado soviético durante la Segunda Guerra Mundial (recurriendo a momentos anteriores para explicar unas cuantas cosas importantes), a sus vivencias, costumbres, tácticas, organización y mil aspectos más, desarrollado en paralelo al transcurso de la propia guerra.¿Quiere saber más de este libro, sin spoilers? Visite:librosdeolethros.


    16. Recomendado para leer con mayor conciencia la historia extraordinaria del Ejército Rojo, sus inimitables objetivos y métodos, y su aplastante victoria en Europa enEuropa en Guerra.


    17. This is an excellently researched text on the realities that the average Russian soldier faced as he confronted the German occupation and eventually the offensive against Germany that brought the end to the War in the European Theater. The Russian losses were astounding, some 8.5 million military dead, part of the total Russian war dead, which were mostly civilian of well over 27,000,000.Stalin actually feared the enemy within more than any enemy from other nations. Brutally even when short of m [...]


    18. For those of us who are true history buffs and love a few hours of reading a thick and juicy non-fiction volume, this book is not only a treat but something I hope all World War II buffs will get their hands on.When it comes to the second world war, we’re all rather associated with the European front in terms of the British, American, and German forces. Rarely do we get a sufficient peek in on the Russian soldiers, and if we do it’s almost never about their lives during the war. Through Cath [...]


    19. Like many others, I've come to realize my teaching in history was lacking, particularly when it came to Russia's role in the Second World War, or as they know it, the Great Patriotic War. American schools show pictures of Normandy on D-Day, but give the barest mention to the millions of lives lost by the Soviet Union in fending off the Nazi menace. Stalingrad, Leningrad, Kursk, Orel, Operation Bagrationne of these places meant anything to me until I really began to study on my own, to see what I [...]


    20. Excellent book; not sure what Bryan Cross was complaining about - Catherine Merridale wasn't in the Red Army so it is unfair to criticize her for not telling the story from the point of view of a Russian veteran. As a researcher, this book was an excellent resource and reference; it's the reader's responsibility going into the book to know what they're getting into. Reviews like this help with that process. And if you're looking for "The Forgotten Soldier" from the perspective of the Soviet side [...]


    21. Really interesting, especially if you have read anything about the experiences of American soldiers in WWII. I know that war was awful for everyone, but it really seems to have been amazingly awful for Russian soldiers. Wrapping one's head around Soviet casualties is really hard; the US lost less than half a million soldiers, while the Soviets lost over 8 million soldiers. Mere days of fighting regularly killed tens of thousands. It's just mind-boggling. And the Americans were fighting for a cou [...]


    22. I forced myself to finish reading this book. Several times I wondered if I was wasting my time. First, this book is not well written. The content is shallow. Second, the author gave a very biased account, probably out of her hatred of all things Soviet. I would estimate 80% of the book talk negatively about the Red Army and the rest is neutral. The book hardly mentions anything positive about the Red Army. I’m not saying that the Red Army is perfect (far from it), but the author’s biased opi [...]


    23. I've seen and read a lot about WWII from the US perspective, but didn't know much about the Soviet experience. When I lived in Russia, each city - no matter the size - had a WWII monument of considerable grandeur. A few Russians even tried to convince me that they won the war, an idea I thought ludicrous at the time. After reading about the national sacrifice of the USSR to win the war, in terms of lives alone, I no longer find the idea ludicrous. One of my favorite moments of the book is an eco [...]


    24. Doing research in the Soviet archives seems like a trying task, but critics revere the work Catherine Merridale did to prepare Ivan's War. The professor from Queen Mary, University of London, conducted over 200 interviews with Soviet veterans and visited major battle sites, but the most enlightening information came from tireless vetting of diaries, transcripts, and officers' reports. That Merridale can plait all this information into "an attempt to fathom war's meaning, effect and legacy" (Fore [...]


    25. I'm a WWII buff, but was more motivated to read this book from the standpoint of having had a very close, dear friend who was drafted (along with the rest of his first year university class) into the Red Army for the Finnish campaign, wounded twice in WWII, and had mentioned some / but never much detail about his own experiences during the war. I'd also spent quite some time as a student in Kharkov, which was occupied twice. This personal connection to the Russian front is what attracted me to t [...]


    26. Really a great book for the avid WWII enthusiast or the piker Goes behind the myths to get at the real sordid story of the Red Army in WWII. She's pretty ruthless about exposing what an insane thing the Soviet Army was and their changing doctrines and purges. And then how they changed in the fire of the Great Patriotic War.


    27. A Russian grunts view of the Second World War. With all the hooplaaround Ken Burns series and "The Greatest Generation", reading this book will be a salutary corrective to the notion that the US military defeated Hitler.At the cost of staggering losses of life, the Red Army pushed the Nazis out of Russia under condtitions that are just unimaginable today.


    28. As the Chinese translator of this one, I admire the author's ability to weave individual experiences, symbolic or not, which she got access to through the intensively exploiting archives & letters & diaries and conducting interviews, into a broader cultural and political narrative.


    29. Did not make it through. The author's style is very chatty and verbose and it really got in the way of the history


    Leave a Reply